EASTERN EUROPE THROUGH POSTCOLONIAL PRISM: ANALYSIS OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18524/2707-5206.2023.36.288717Keywords:
postcolonialism, post-communism, Eastern Europe, Russian-Ukrainian war, empiresAbstract
The article examines the application of postcolonial theory to the analysis of the political transformations in post-communist countries in Eastern Europe. The question of the relevance of the application has become particularly important after the Russian full scale invasion of Ukraine. The question of the relevance of the application has become particularly important after the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine. There is an obvious contradiction between the wide-spreading usages of the terms colonialism in the public discourse to characterize the essence of Russian aggressive policy and the near absence of scientific interpretation of this dramatic conflict from the postcolonial researchers. In order to investigate the reasons for the situation, the article raises the question about “double silence” – mutual ignoring by both postcolonial researchers of the Eastern European region and researchers of post-communist transformations of the colonial experience of Eastern European countries. We used a content analysis of the post-colonial scientific for the period from 2000 to obtain data on the number of publications about Eastern Europe. The content analysis proves the idea of the marginal character of Eastern European research within the framework of postcolonial theory and shows the complete absence of scientific interpretation of the Russian-Ukrainian war from a postcolonial perspective. The article considers the main reasons for this situation: the low level of interest in the region of Eastern Europe from Western scholars; the Marxist views of many researchers, which exclude the possibility of identifying colonialism not only with the capitalist states of the West but also with the socialist USSR; the dominance of the Russian-centric discourse in the scientific community. At the same time, examples of the combination of postcolonial theory and transitology to the analysis of social and political transformations in the region of Eastern Europe are given.
References
Cavanagh, С. (2003). Postkolonialna Polska. Biała plama na mapie współczesnej teorii. Teksty Drugie, 2–3, 60–71 [in Polish]. [Cavanagh С. Postkolonialna Polska. Biała plama na mapie współczesnej teorii. Teksty Drugie. 2003. No 2–3. P. 60–71.]
East Central Europe Between the Colonial and the Postcolonial in the Twentieth Century (2023). OAPEN. Retrieved from: https://library.oapen.org/handle/20.500.12657/62375 [in English].
Gundorova, T. (2014). Generational challenge and postcolonialism in Eastern Europe. Introductory remarks. Postcolonialism. Generations. Culture. Kyiv: Laurus, 7–13 [in Ukrainian]. [Гундорова Т. Генераційний виклик і постколоніалізм на сході Європи. Вступні зауваження. Постколоніалізм. Генерації. Культура / за ред. Т. Гундорової, А. Матусяк. Київ : Лаурус, 2014. С. 7–13.]
Kołodziejczyk, D., Sandru, C. (2012, May). Introduction: On colonialism, communism and east-central Europe – some reflections. Journal of Postcolonial Writing, 48(2), 113–116 [in English].
Korek, Janusz (Ed.) (2007). From Sovietology to Postcoloniality: Poland and Ukraine from a Postcolonial Perspective. Stockholm: Södertörn Academic Studies, 32, 272 p. [in English].
Mälksoo, М. (2022, May 11). The Postcolonial Moment in Russia’s War Against Ukraine. Journal of Genocide Research. Retrieved from: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14623528.2022.2074947 [in English].
Moore, D. C. (2001). Is the Post- in Postcolonial the Post- in Post-Soviet? Toward a Global Postcolonial Critique. PMLA, 116(1), 111–128 [in English].
Mukherjee, S., Roy, M. (2021). The Postcolonial Nature of the Post-Soviet Space: a reading of the cultural condition of Albania. Balkanistic Forum, 30(3), 369–385 [in English].
Partlett, W., Küpper, H. (2022). The Post-Soviet as Post-Colonial: A New Paradigm for Understanding Constitutional Dynamics in the Former Soviet Empire. Edward Elgar Publishing, 288 р. [in English].
Riabchuk, M. (2013, July 23). Ukraine is not Africa. But what? Zbruc. Retrieved from: https://zbruc.eu/node/10508 [in Ukrainian]. [Рябчук М. Україна – не Африка. Але що? Збруч. 2013. 23 липня. URL: https://zbruc.eu/node/10508 (дата звернення: 19.06.2023).]
Russia is waging colonial war against Ukraine – Austrian president (2023, February 1). Ukrinform. Retrieved from: https://www.ukrinform.net/rubric-polytics/3663357-russia-waging-colonial-war-against-ukraine-austrian-president.html [in Ukrainian]. [Росія веде проти України колоніальну війну – президент Австрії. Укрінформ. 2023. 1 лютого. URL: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-polytics/3663342-rosia-vede-proti-ukraini-kolonialnu-vijnu-prezident-avstrii.html (дата звернення: 15.06.2023).]
Russia’s war in Ukraine is a colonial war. We are dealing with an absolutely genocidal plan – His Beatitude Sviatoslav (2023, March 15). Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. Retrieved from: https://ugcc.ua/data/viyna-rosiy-v-ukrayni-kolonialna-viyna-my-maemo-spravu-z-absolyutno-genotsydnym-planom-blazhennishyy-svyatoslav-2353/ [in Ukrainian]. [«Війна Росії в Україні – колоніальна війна. Ми маємо справу з абсолютно геноцидним планом», – Блаженніший Святослав. Українська греко-католицька церква. 2023. 15 березня. URL: https://ugcc.ua/data/viyna-rosiy-v-ukrayni-kolonialna-viyna-my-maemo-spravu-z-absolyutno-genotsydnym-planom-blazhennishyy-svyatoslav-2353/ (дата звернення: 15.06.2023).]
Said, E. (2001). Orientalism. Kyiv: Osnovy [in Ukrainian]. [Саїд Е. Орієнталізм. Київ : Основи, 2001. 511 с.]
Said, E. (2007). Culture and Imperialism. Kyiv: Krytyka [in Ukrainian]. [Саїд Е. Культура й імперіалізм. Київ : Критика, 2007. 608 с.]
Skórczewski, D. (2013). Troubling Post-colonies of Europe. East / West Journal. Neo-anti-colonialism vs neo-imperialism: the relevance of the postcolonial discourse in the post-soviet space, 16, 30–42 [in Ukrainian]. [Скурчевський Д. Клопітні (пост)колонії Європи. Схід / Захід. Нео-анти-колоніалізм vs нео-імперіалізм: релевантність постколоніального дискурсу на пострадянському просторі. 2013. Вип. 16. С. 30–42.]
Smolii, V. А., & Yas, О. V. (2022). The contemporary Russian-Ukrainian war in the light of postcolonialism. Visnyk of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, 6, 3–15 [in Ukrainian]. [Cмолій В. А., Ясь О. В. Сучасна російсько-українська війна у світлі постколоніалізму. Вісник НАН України. 2022. № 6. C. 3–15.]
Snyder, T. (2022, April 28). The war in Ukraine is a Colonial War. The New Yorker. Retrieved from: https://www.newyorker.com/news/essay/the-war-in-ukraine-is-a-colonial-war [in English].
Thompson, E. M. (2008). Imperial Knowledge: Russian Literature and Colonialism. Kyiv: Osnovy, 368 р. [in Ukrainian]. [Томпсон Е. М. Трубадури імперії: Російська література і колоніалізм. Київ : Основи, 2008. 368 с.]
Thompson, E. M. (2019, June 3). Polska I Rosja Postkolonialne. Teologia Polityczna. Retrieved from: https://teologiapolityczna.pl/ewa-thompson-polska-i-rosja-postkolonialne [in Polish]. [Thompson E. M. Polska I Rosja Postkolonialne. Teologia Polityczna. 2019. June 3. URL: https://teologiapolityczna.pl/ewa-thompson-polska-i-rosja-postkolonialne (дата звернення: 17.06.2023).]
Wolff, L. (2009). Inventing Eastern Europe. The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment. Kyiv: Krytyka, 592 р. [in Ukrainian]. [Вулф Л. Винайдення Східної Європи. Мапа цивілізації у свідомості епохи Просвітництва. Київ : Критика, 2009. 592 с.]
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 The rightholders of publication are authors as well as a founder of the Journal on conditions determined by publishing agreement, concluded between editorial board and authors of articles. No part of published material can be reproduced without preliminary notification and permission of author. Publication of works in Journal is realized on a not-for-profit basis. Author has a right to publish his work in any other mass media without permission of the editorial board with no reference to Journal, but with giving notice to the journal editorial board about publication of his work in the other mass media. Editorial board has a right to publish author’s work in the other mass media, but with permission of an author.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
The rightholders of publication are authors as well as a founder of the Journal on conditions determined by publishing agreement, concluded between editorial board and authors of articles. No part of published material can be reproduced without preliminary notification and permission of author.
Publication of works in Journal is realized on a not-for-profit basis.
Author has a right to publish his work in any other mass media without permission of the editorial board with no reference to Journal, but with giving notice to the journal editorial board about publication of his work in the other mass media.
Editorial board has a right to publish author’s work in the other mass media, but with permission of an author.
